Riot police were deployed outside Poland's Constitutional Tribunal on Friday night as the country's deepening judicial crisis spilled into the streets, with President Karol Nawrocki forcing his way past security cordons to intervene after his government moved to suspend the court's top two judges.
The confrontation stems from a decade-long dispute over the court's legitimacy. The right-wing Law and Justice party, which governed until late 2023, appointed judges to secure a majority on the tribunal because it has final say over whether legislation is constitutional. The European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice of the European Union both ruled that three of those judges were improperly appointed, duplicating positions already validly filled.
Prime Minister Tusk has vowed to depoliticize the judiciary and has used the European rulings as grounds to stop publishing the tribunal's decisions. His attempt to undo the PiS-era judicial changes has stalled: Nawrocki and his PiS-backed predecessor both vetoed his efforts, and Nawrocki has refused to swear in five judges elected by parliament since March.
Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek requested stripping the court's President Bogdan Święczkowski and Vice-President Bartłomiej Sochański of immunity to bring criminal charges. A group of government-appointed judges then suspended both men. The move triggered protests outside the court building, with hundreds of opposition MPs and supporters gathering. Police detained three people after some protesters breached the tribunal's fence and threw objects at officers. Nawrocki, who is backed by PiS and is a close ally of Donald Trump, cancelled a state visit to Senegal mid-flight to return to Warsaw. Shortly before 1am on Saturday, video footage showed him forcing his way through the police cordon, tussling with security and other judges to enter the building.
As of 4am local time, Nawrocki remained inside. In a statement read on his behalf at 5am, he called the move "a violation of Poland's constitutional order" and said "a constitutional body was seized by force." The Constitutional Court issued a social media post stating that Święczkowski and Sochański remain the legally appointed senior justices and wrote: "All persons participating in these actions are committing the crime of a coup d'etat." Tusk defended the government's actions in a post, writing: "Restoring the rule of law is our duty. After years of Law and Justice's lawlessness, this is a difficult, sometimes painful process that requires decisive action."
The confrontation pits the ruling centrist government under Tusk against both the court's PiS-backed leadership and the right-wing opposition, which holds a real chance of returning to power in next year's parliamentary election according to current polling. The clash is likely to further polarize the country ahead of that vote.
Neither side recognizes the other's authority: the government has stopped publishing the tribunal's rulings based on European court findings of improper appointments, while the court insists its suspended judges remain the only legitimate heads of the institution. The standoff reflects the failure of Tusk's attempts to undo judicial changes made under PiS rule without the cooperation of the presidency, which is held by a PiS ally.
The crisis remains unresolved with Nawrocki inside the building and no clear path to de-escalation. Poland's judicial system now operates with competing claims of legitimacy from both the government and the court itself.


