Canada's spy watchdog has flagged significant privacy risks in the military's online intelligence activities, saying the Defence Department and Canadian Armed Forces do not sufficiently protect Canadians' data despite having legal authority to collect publicly available information from the internet.
The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency released its findings after examining how the military gathers open-source information online. The watchdog said publicly available data still raises privacy concerns when collected and analyzed by government organizations for intelligence purposes. Canadians should be able to trust that such collection has a clear, lawful purpose and respects their privacy rights, the agency stated.
The review found two specific failures in the military's practices. First, the Defence Department does not systematically record the link between open-source collection activities on the internet and the approved operation or defence activity that justified the gathering. Second, policies and record-keeping do not adequately address all privacy risks or demonstrate that collection involving Canadians is necessary. The watchdog noted these shortcomings exist even though the military has clear legal authority to collect such information.
The gaps in oversight and documentation mean the military can collect information about Canadian citizens online without consistently demonstrating why the collection serves a lawful intelligence purpose or why it meets the test of necessity. The lack of systematic record-keeping prevents both internal review and external oversight of whether collection activities remain proportionate to their stated objectives.
The findings arrive as Parliament considers Bill C-22, legislation that would expand the authority of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service to collect and analyze information, including online data, according to reporting by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms. The watchdog's critique suggests that privacy protections will need to be built into any such expansion.

